Every practice buys IT one of two ways, even if nobody ever named them. Either you pay when something breaks, or you pay someone to stop things breaking and to own the security work in between. Neither is wrong. They solve different problems, and the expensive mistake is buying one while expecting the other.
What break/fix actually means
Break/fix is the repair model. A computer won't start, the printer stops talking to the front desk, a sensor driver fails after an update. You call, someone fixes it. Traditionally that meant an hourly bill and a wait for whoever was free. The appeal is easy to see: you only pay when there's a problem.
The catch is just as easy to see once you say it out loud. Nobody is paid to notice the failing hard drive, the backup that quietly stopped running in March, or the login that still belongs to someone who left last year. Break/fix is reactive by design. It does exactly what its name says.
What managed IT actually means
Managed IT flips the incentive. You pay a flat monthly amount and the provider is responsible for the whole environment: monitoring, updates, security tools, backups, and a help desk for everyday questions. Because the fee doesn't go up when things break, the provider does best when your systems are quiet.
For a healthcare practice, managed IT also covers the part a repair plan never touches: the HIPAA risk assessment, written policies, and proof that the safeguards are actually running. That paperwork is what an auditor or a cyber insurer asks for (source: 45 CFR 164.316), and it has to be kept current by someone.
Where break/fix fits a practice
Break/fix is a reasonable choice when your needs are mostly mechanical. You have a modest number of computers. Your practice software is hosted by its vendor. Someone else already owns your HIPAA documentation, whether that's a compliance consultant, a parent organization, or an office manager who really does keep it up. What you want is a competent person on call who knows healthcare systems.
That's why our Break/Fix plan is a subscription instead of an hourly rate. Remote repairs and three on-site visits per month per practice are included, along with monitoring, software updates, and threat detection on every covered machine. Repairing a computer we can't see is slower for everyone, so the monitoring comes with it.
Where it stops fitting
Break/fix stops fitting the moment the question changes from "is the computer working?" to "can we prove we're protecting patient data?" A repair plan doesn't include a risk assessment, written policies, tamper-proof backups with tested restores, or anyone managing your Microsoft 365 sign-in rules. If someone asks for that evidence, a repair plan has nothing to hand over.
The other sign is volume. If your staff call about everyday things, like a new hire's account, a shared mailbox, or how to send something securely, that is help-desk work. A plan built around repairs will feel thin within a few months.
What each one costs
The comparison is simpler than it looks. Break/Fix is priced per computer. Tier 1 and Tier 2 are priced per person, and Tier 2 adds 24/7 support. Tell us how many computers and people you have, and you get one monthly number for each plan, in writing, so you can set them side by side.
The gap between those numbers isn't margin for the same work. It pays for the full security baseline, tamper-proof backup with restores tested every quarter, and the compliance paperwork. Whether that gap is worth it depends entirely on whether someone is already doing that work for you.
How to decide
Ask three questions. Who is our named HIPAA security official, as the rule requires? If the honest answer is "nobody," you need managed IT or another way to fill that role. (source: 45 CFR 164.308) Could we restore our data tomorrow, and when did we last test it? If you're not sure, you need managed IT. Do we mostly need things fixed when they break? If yes, and the first two answers are solid, break/fix will serve you well.
The takeaway
Buy the model that matches the problem you actually have. Break/fix is honest, affordable repair coverage. Managed IT is repair coverage plus prevention plus proof. Every plan we offer is month-to-month, so starting with one never locks you out of the other.